Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Nancy A McLoughlin
Licensed Real Estate Associate Broker
REALTOR®, Licensed Broker Associate, CLHMS, CHMS, CBR CSSR
Cell: (631) 796-6118
Zillow Icon 
Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    43
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 48 ratings.
38 user reviews.
Includes 5 Zillow reviews
Photo of Nancy A McLoughlin
Nancy A McLoughlin
See My Zillow Profile

Nancy was the best, quickly addressing any concerns I had. She went above and beyond to keep me informed and calm through a stressful time.

E. B. | Home Seller

"Nancy was outstanding in every way. She advised us will in terms of strategy and pricing, she made showing our home easy and negotiated a great offer over asking price to ensure we got the very best terms. She is knowledgeable, professional, and truly pleasant to work with A+!"

Donna DePasquale | Home Seller

"Nancy was spectacular. This was a tough period in my life, but with her assistance and expertise, the sale went very smoothly".

S. S. | Home Seller

"Nancy was great. She guided us through the sales process expertly and patiently. Her confidence was reassuring during a difficult real estate market. A true professional and friend".

P. C. | Home Seller

I was very pleased with working with Nancy. She was always so professional and courteous. I would refer her to family and friends.

Katherine I. | Home Seller

We were very happy working with Nancy. She was courteous and very knowledgeable. We would refer her to family and friends.

Rhonda K. & Timothy G. | Home Seller

Nancy was wonderful to work with. She was always professional and courteous. I would be happy to refer her to family & friends.

Angela A. | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Nancy was great to work with, always so knowledgeable and professional. We would refer her to family and friends.

Alyson & Erik S. | Home Buyer

We were very pleased with Nancy. She was so knowledgeable and professional. We would recommend her to family and friends.

Jeff & Nancy S. | Home Seller

Nancy went above and beyond to get our property sold. We would work with her again without hesitation.

Ken N. | Home Seller

Nancy McLoughlin was a pleasure to work with. Sher is very knowledgeable and professional. We are so happy in our new home!

Mandy P. | Home Buyer

Nancy was wonderful to work with, very caring and kind. She knew all of the answers to questions that I asked and more. She also responded to texts/calls immediately. Thank you, Nancy!

Jarrett M. | Home Buyer

"Nancy was professional and courteous, I would refer her to my family and friends."

J. C. | Home Seller

"Yes, we are off to a great start thanks to Nancy!!! However, we miss Nancy and Steve, our neighbors and friends like you".

T M | Home Seller

Nancy was everything we wanted in a sales associate and more. She was very professional, courteous, and made us comfortable. 10/10 would use her again.

D. G. | Home Buyer

I have dealt with Nancy multiple times and I'm very impressed with her expertise and how she handles dealing with difficult situations and makes you feel at ease. Great Job

Mary Ackerman

Nancy was a "breath of fresh air". I was listed with an agent from a different company. I was so disgusted with the agent that we almost took our house off the market. Nancy came in and showed us really how it should be done. The reason we chose Nancy was because she showed our house more than anyone, even the listing agent. So we decided to sign on with her. She did a lot of marketing and really knew how to make a deal happen. I have already recommended her to family and friends and will continue to.

Carol A. | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Nancy was a pleasure to deal with and very very professional sales person. This was not an easy deal and she never lost her cool. A great person, my best to her and her family.

Frank P. | Home Buyer

Would recommend Nancy to anyone looking to buy or sell there home.

Alyson S. | Home Buyer

Nancy was much more than a sales associate, she was "there for me", at a very emotional time.

Carol Mc. | Home Seller

Great experience! Nancy is very professional. Her personally is warm and friendly.

Karen B. | Home Seller

We were very satisfied with Nancy and the entire process. Thank you.

Dee S. | Home Seller

We loved working with Nancy. She couldn't have made our experience any better.

Nicole C. | Home Buyer

Thank you for a great job!

Carol D. | Home Seller

Nancy was great!

Mindy M. | Home Seller

Nancy went above and beyond doing her job. Great person, great asset to Coach.

Carol M. | Home Seller

Please feel free to use me as a reference, I would recommend Nancy to friends and family.

Christine D. | Home Buyer

Thank you for a great job!

Charlie R. | Home Buyer

Nancy could not have been better in every way.

Michael B. | Home Seller

Our experience was fantastic, Nancy is the best.

Marie H. | Home Buyer

Nancy is caring and a hard worker. She said "not to worry it will all work out." And she was right! Great job Nancy

Tim G. | Home Seller

I cannot begin to describe the exceptional service and the "can do" attitude with which Nancy addressed her business. She went so far above and beyond. She guided us and created a flawless experience. We were complete novices having never purchased (nor owned) a home. She casually, comfortably led us through the entire process. Not only that, she was always accessible, responsive, an patient to our incessant questions and requests for advice and favors. We had no realtor of our own,(she was the listing agent) and was fair, impartial, and careful to take care of all parties involved. We are so grateful to Nancy and sincerely appreciate her. Thank you!

Caterina V. | Home Buyer

Nancy just recently sold my son's land in East Northport. She was totally professional and knows her business well. She had to go to Town Hall many times since various questions arose that needed answers. She kept me up to date and followed through with all of her leads in order to sell. I was very pleased with her role as sales agent and would highly recommend her.

Carol H | Home Seller

Nancy made herself so accessible, whenever a question or concern came up she always got right back to us and was ready to help. She went above and beyond to help us get the house ready to be sold. I would gladly recommend Nancy to anyone who askes me for a great realtor.

Monique | Home Buyer

Nancy was a wonderful agent, always very helpful and also had good recommendations for various contractors after the closing. I would highly refer her.

Rhyse Mc. | Home Buyer

Nancy Was an excellent sales person. I would recommend her highly. I was very stressed and she kept me calm.

Dorothy Citrin | Home Seller

Nancy did a great job. Above and beyond! We were extremely happy with her performance.

Mark Finley | Home Seller

Nancy went above and beyond during the sales process. She was AMAZING! Moving is a very stressful situation and she made it so easy.

Frank & Shari Raffone | Home Seller & Home Buyer

Nancy was awesome. She is extremely knowledgeable and thorough. She assisted my wife and I through the entire buying process. She is a very calming influence during what can be a stressfull time. I would not hesitate to use Nancy again and recommend her highly to any one.

Nancy McLoughlin has made buying my condo an easy process and a stress free time. Nancy McLoughlin was informative in her details regarding her description of the inside of the condo that I was seeking for. Also Nancy McLoughlin was always prompt and made every aspect of buying a condo hassle free, I would always recommend Nancy McLoughlin to all of my friends.

NANCY WORKED VERY HARD TRYING TO SELL MY PARENTS AFTER THEY WENT INTO THE NURSING HOME.. IT STARTED IN APRIL OF 2011 AND IT HAD TO GET SOLD BUY DEC OF 2011 SO THE NURSING HOME WOULDN'T GRAB MY PARENTS HOME.. WITH SO MANY OPEN HOUSES .. AND REACHING OUT TO OTHER REAL ESTATE... NANCY WAS DETERMINED TO GET THE JOB DONE.. WHICH SHE DID ... BY DEC 2011 MY PARENTS HOUSE WAS SOLD AT A FARE VALUE PRICE... THANK YOU NANCY

Nancy was reliable, knowledgeable, responsive, and actively engaged throughout the whole process of selling our home. She was a pleasure to work with, very professional, and we highly recommend her.

Nancy went the extra mile in every aspect of my home buying experience. She spent countless hours providing all the information I needed to make a sound buying decision. I have referred several people to Nancy, and they have had the same experience. Kudo's to Nancy and Coach Realtors!

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/22/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/22/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Fri 05/22/2026 8:36:54 AM EST) or OneKey MLS (last updated Fri 05/22/2026 8:29:24 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Howard Hanna | Coach Realtors may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: https://www.coachrealtors.com New York State Real Estate Broker Principal Office License Number: 10991237973


Login to My Homefinder

Pixel